Google defends UK tax arrangements – BBC News

12 months ago Comments Off on Google defends UK tax arrangements – BBC News
Media captionWhen asked about his salary Mr Brittin said he did not have the figure

Google’s UK chief has defended the search giant’s tax arrangements in a hearing before MPs on the Commons Public Accounts Committee.

Matt Brittin said he understood public anger about the amount of tax it paid.

However, he said Google was paying 20% tax on its UK profits, not the 3% figure cited in some reports.

The £130m in UK tax it paid for the 10 years from 2005 was reached following a “six-year rigorous, independent tax audit” by HMRC, Mr Brittin said.

Tom Hutchinson, Google’s global tax chief, told MPs that the company did not negotiate its tax settlement with HMRC.

He told the committee that the tax authorities did not “throw out a number – it’s not a negotiation”, adding: “There was no top-line figure; that’s not how the process works.”

The £130m payment included £18m in interest, Mr Hutchinson told MPs, but no penalties or payments under the government’s diverted profits tax – also known as the “Google tax”.

MPs also questioned HMRC officials about their settlement with Google.

Jim Harra, its head of business taxation, said the company was not fined, despite underpaying tax, because proving “insufficient care” was “very difficult”.

Dame Lin Homer, HMRC chief executive, admitted that the six-year investigation into Google’s tax affairs took a long time to complete, but said that similar inquiries into far smaller firms could be just as lengthy.

Image caption

HMRC chief Dame Lin Horner

Mr Brittin said there had been no co-ordination with the Treasury about the timing of Google’s announcement about the tax settlement late last month. The Chancellor, George Osborne, described it as a victory for the government.

The timing was determined by the fact that the figure was due to be made public when the company’s UK accounts were filed, Mr Brittin said.

Dame Lin told MPs that HMRC informed the relevant minister that a big company was to make a tax announcement the following day, but did not name the firm.

Tax reform call

“What we don’t, and never, do is share taxpayer information with ministers and Treasury colleagues,” she said.

In an article for the Telegraph published on Thursday, Mr Brittin said Google wanted the international tax system to be reformed.

He said the company paid $3.3bn in corporation tax last year, mostly in the US, where most of Google’s products were designed and created.

Image copyright
Getty Images

“We have long been in favour of simpler, clearer rules, because it is important not only to pay the right amount of tax, but to be seen to be paying the right amount,” Mr Brittin wrote.

“But changes to the tax system are not Google’s call. Reform must come from governments, not from the companies who are subject to their rules.”

He was asked four times by Meg Hillier, chair of the Public Accounts Committee, how much he was paid. Mr Brittin said: “I don’t have the figure, but I will happily provide it.”

“You don’t know what you get paid?” responded Ms Hillier.

“Out there, taxpayers, our constituents, are very angry, they live in a different world clearly to the world you live in, if you can’t even tell us what you are paid.”

Google defends UK tax arrangements – BBC News