The FBI should try to unlock a shooter’s iPhone without Apple’s help, a lawmaker says – PCWorld

11 months ago Comments Off on The FBI should try to unlock a shooter’s iPhone without Apple’s help, a lawmaker says – PCWorld

The FBI might be able to copy the hard drive of an iPhone used by a mass shooter without triggering the device’s auto-erase functions, thus eliminating the agency’s need to take Apple to court, a company executive said Tuesday.

Instead of forcing Apple to help defeat the iPhone password security that erases the device’s contents after 10 unsuccessful attempts, it may be possible to make hundreds of copies of the hard drive, said Bruce Sewell, Apple’s senior vice president and general counsel.

Apple doesn’t know the condition of the iPhone used by San Bernardino mass shooter Syed Rizwan Farook, so it’s unclear if mirroring the hard drive would work, but it’s possible, Sewell said during a congressional hearing.

The suggestion that the FBI attempt to copy the iPhone’s hard drive first came from Representative Darrell Issa, a California Republican and former car-alarm entrepreneur.

The design of the older model iPhone 5c may allow investigators to remove its hard drive and make multiple copies, Issa said. Investigators could then run 10 password attempts on each copy until they found the correct password, he said.

“The FBI is the premier law enforcement organization, with laboratories that are second to none in the world,” Issa told FBI Director James Comey. “Are you testifying today that you and/or contractors that you employ could not achieve this without demanding that an unwilling partner do it?”

The FBI has explored other options and found none that it believes will work without Apple’s assistance in defeating the password protection, Comey said. “We have engaged all parts of the U.S. government” to find ways to gain access to information on the phone without Apple’s help, he said. “If we could have done this quietly and privately, we would have done it.”

Sewell and Comey both faced tough questions during the hearing, which was focused on the pending court case and on smartphone encryption. Both men largely repeated their talking points from the long-running debate on device encryption, but lawmakers seemed split on whether Apple should honor the FBI’s request and Magistrate Judge Sheri Pym’s Feb. 16 order requiring the company to comply.

The FBI should try to unlock a shooter’s iPhone without Apple’s help, a lawmaker says – PCWorld